Some scholars look within nations to explain the source of current dissatisfaction with open market. Economists offer an 26 view that over time, trade should be increasingly valued by voters. This is because the new and more 27 consumer goods are available for purchase. Also, more exports opportunities 28 growth and employment. However, all these gains are not taken for granted in politics. One reason for this is that although consumer prices have declined and exports grown, job gains are 29 . Even if history ultimately reveals a positive relationship between job growth and globalization, the potential benefits of globalization have been 30 by increasingly long value chains, by job growth in less legible service sectors, and by the geographic consolidation of winners.