Under the Article 189 of the Civil Code, the proprietor is liable for third party's injury caused by the contractor's negligence ONLY if:
AThe proprietor wrongfully selected the contractor.
BThe proprietor wrongfully supervised the contractor.
CThe work which caused injury was under the negligent instruction of the proprietor.正確答案
DThe work which caused injury was under the negligent instruction of the contractor.
C正確答案
民法第189條:承攬人執行承攬事項加害第三人,定作人原則上不負責,除非定作人於定作或指示有過失。
逐選項解析
AThe proprietor wrongfully selected the contractor.✕ 易錯陷阱
「選任過失」是民法第188條僱用人責任的要件,不是第189條定作人責任的要件。題目問的是承攬關係,不是僱傭關係,考生最容易混淆於此。
BThe proprietor wrongfully supervised the contractor.✕ 易錯陷阱
「監督過失」同樣是僱用人責任(§188)的概念。承攬人具獨立性,定作人原則上不監督其工作過程,因此監督過失並非第189條的歸責基礎。
CThe work which caused injury was under the negligent instruction of the proprietor.✓ 正確
DThe work which caused injury was under the negligent instruction of the contractor.✕ 易錯陷阱
立即註冊,看完整詳解
這題的完整詳解,註冊就能看 · 每天 2 題免費
精選詳解- 完整逐選項解析
- 秒殺解題技巧與破題關鍵
- 關鍵知識表整理
- 陷阱與易錯提醒
- 同考點歷屆題庫連續刷題與錯題本
綜合法學(二)(公司法、保險法、票據法、證券交易法、強制執行法、法學英文) 相關題目