In general, the court must be held in public unless under certain circumstances. Which of the following situations is NOT the exception for the public court?
AThe controversy involves personal privacy.
BThe controversy involves individual's freedom of speech.正確答案
CThe controversy involves business secret.
DBoth parties have consented the hearing not be held in public.
答案與詳解
B
正確答案
題目問「不是」公開審判例外：單純涉及言論自由不構成不公開事由，選B。
逐選項解析
AThe controversy involves personal privacy.✕ 錯誤
personal privacy指個人隱私。依民事訴訟法第195-1條，攻擊或防禦方法涉及當事人或第三人隱私，經當事人聲請且法院認為適當者，得不公開審判，因此A屬可能例外，不是本題答案。
BThe controversy involves individual's freedom of speech.✓ 正確
CThe controversy involves business secret.✕ 錯誤
business secret指業務秘密。依民事訴訟法第195-1條，攻擊或防禦方法涉及業務秘密，經當事人聲請且法院認為適當者，得不公開審判，因此C屬可能例外，不是本題答案。
DBoth parties have consented the hearing not be held in public.✕ 易錯陷阱
